I wanted to wait until after the funeral to post this. I didn't want to detract from this very sad event to rant about the idiocy of those who comment on online news articles.
My heart goes out to the family and community that lost an exceptional young man/friend/brother/father/husband/colleague. He deserved better than this.
May he rest in peace.
* * *
All I keep reading are excuses. In response to the tragic death of Garrett Styles, I see excuses. I’m not talking about the police force. I’m talking about parents.
If you haven’t already heard, the short version is a traffic cop pulled over a mini-van around 5am for speeding at ~145 km/h (90 mph). Inside, were a bunch of joyriding teens. The driver is 15-years old (under the legal driving age) and had stolen his dad’s mini-van. After being pulled over and having some dialogue, the police officer reached into the car in attempt to remove the keys from the ignition. The teen then accelerated, dragged the police officer approximately 300m (~980 feet) and lost control of the vehicle, which then flipped over on top the police officer. Styles was pinned under the vehicle from the waist down. He radioed for help, all the while expressing concern for the teens in the vehicle, and then died in the hospital.
Fatally wounded Ontario police officer pleads for help from beneath minivan
Like many others, when I heard the news, I was horrified. And yes, in addition to blaming that heartless and stupid child, I blamed the parents. I still blame the parents. And I am heartily sick of reading all these comments that are just excuses.
You can’t control teenagers.
Do you know how hard it is to raise a child?
If the teenager was brave enough to steal his father’s car, what could the father do?
How about this? These parents had 15 years to raise this child properly. The only out that the parents would get is if this 15-year old has some sort of mental illness. Otherwise, I’m sorry. There’s absolutely no excuse anyone could possible give that would cause me to absolve the parents of any responsibility whatsoever. I’m not saying it’s 100% the parents’ fault, but they’re also not faultless.
Garrett Styles was 32 years old. He was going to turn 33 on Sunday, July 3rd. His son is 9-weeks old. His daughter is 2 years old. He did not die while fighting in a war, defending his country. He did not die in an attempt to save a child from a burning building. He did not even die of cancer. He died a completely avoidable and senseless death because of irresponsible parents and a reckless teenager. And all I see from commenters on the news articles is how it’s not the parents’ fault.
I’m sick and tired of hearing people making excuses for poor parenting. There is no excuse for not raising one’s child properly to become a respectable member of society. No one ever said it was easy. But the fact that it’s not easy doesn’t mean that it’s okay for parents to fail and not take any accountability for it.
I was not the easiest of children to raise. I’m not perfect. But dammit, at NO POINT during my teenaged-angst-filled years would I have dragged a police officer with ANY car – let alone stolen my parent’s car. I wouldn’t even have mouthed off to a police officer. I’m not the biggest fan of cops, but I definitely had the fear of God in me when it came to the police. Maybe it’s because I’ve got a high moral compass. Maybe it’s because uniforms intimidate me. Maybe it’s because I understand that the police have a bit of authority. Regardless, I’m pretty sure part of it is due to the way my parents raised me. Know right from wrong, and the police are here to help.
I’m a child of immigrants. My mother spoke neither English nor French while we were living in Montreal. The need for French disappeared when my family moved to Toronto, but she still didn’t speak English. My family was very poor and my parents worked incredibly long hours just to make ends meet. I can go on and on about all the things my friends and classmates had that I didn’t have, but the only point I want to make is, despite not having 24-7 dedicated, full-time parenting, my brother and I both turned out ok. My parents, despite all the challenges they had to overcome, still managed to teach my brother and I the difference between right and wrong.
But this isn’t about comparing to me. I have nothing to do with this situation, being acquainted with neither the teen nor the officer. This is about the senselessness of the entire situation.
The other excuse I just love (yes, there was a contemptuous eye-roll in there) is the one about how the cop should not have reached in the car to try and get the keys. You know what? They’re right. He shouldn’t have done that. BUT…getting dragged 300m and then dying while pinned under a car is supposed to be the “acceptable” consequence for such a mistake? Really? REALLY!?!? “But you never know what might happen.” Right, but he didn’t reach into the vehicle of thugs or drug dealers or even a scary trucker. It was a 15-year old kid behind the wheel.
WHAT KIND OF SOCIETY DO WE LIVE IN THAT WE’RE SUPPOSED TO BE AFRAID OF GETTING KILLED BY A 15-YEAR OLD KID?!!?!?
I hate that this tragedy has spawned a rant. And being that the accused is a minor, there’s no information released about his so my view is incredibly one-sided. Perhaps there is another side to this story. And I reserve that for the trial, judge and jury.
Since there are no laws against bad parenting, his parents will not be held accountable for their failures. Since he is a minor (I highly doubt he will be tried as an adult), if convicted, he’ll probably be out in less than 10 years. Maybe he would’ve learned his lesson by then. For everyone who says, “But he’s not a murderer. There was no intent,” maybe you’re right. But he failed to have any regard for life of another, the authority of a police officer and the law. If it wasn’t a police officer who was killed…if it was a pregnant mom, on her way to work…if it was a 4-year boy on his way to school…if it was your best friend, your husband, your wife, your child… what would you call it then?
I’m don’t care for any of the excuses being thrown around.
As far as I’m concerned:
- He stole a car.
- He’s unlicenced AND under the legal driving age.
- He was speeding 40% faster than the legal speed limit.
- He endangered his friends.
- He endangered the lives of anyone else who might have been on that road.
- He disregarded the authority of a law enforcement officer.
- He dragged a police officer 300 m. (Maybe he was scared and not thinking, but what other possible outcome besides injury and/or death could there be?)
- His actions killed the police officer.
This teenager isn’t Paul Bernardo, but he’s also not innocent. Garrett Styles perhaps should not have reached for the keys to the car, but that does not transfer any of the responsibility of the outcome to him. It’s not Garrett Styles’ fault that he died. In fact, this 15-year old’s parents are more responsible for the outcome than Styles. Ultimately, the responsibility lies with the teenager. In spite of all the errors he made that morning, he could have been forgiven. That is, up until he pressed the gas pedal. At that exact point, he became the sole person responsible for ending a life. And there are no reasons or excuses that anyone can offer that would absolve him of that.