I might be the only one, and judging by the speed at which everyone leapt to their feet for the standing O, I probably was, but I didn't like it.
Before all the Itzhak Perlman fans scream in uproar, let me start with the fact that I truly believe he is a great violinist. However, everyone has less than stellar performances, and music is quite subjective. So while everyone else in Roy Thomson Hall may have loved Itzhak's interpretation of Tchaikovsky's Violin Concerto, I did not.
Source: Violin
This is a piece to showcase the violin...the soloist. But I felt like the entire orchestra was held back, suppressed both in volume and speed to the point where they sounded bound and gagged. The piece didn't flow lyrically with grace and ease, but dragged cumbersomely with odd pauses in some spots and awkwardly rushed passage to catch up. There were times, too many times, when the orchestra was out of sync with the violin. This was even more noticeable when the violin solo had its "dialogue" with the flute solo and clarinet solo. It was, as the Chinese euphemism goes, like a duck and a chicken trying to have a conversation.
Source: Duck & Chicken
Many things about tonight's performance threw me off. Aside from the over all timing being messed up, there was also the matter of odd volume drops from the orchestra. This concerto already has very few full orchestra passages. So when the orchestra passages are being played, I expect that they should be prominent. Instead, the first bar came out the way I expected, only to be suddenly stifled for the remaining bars as if Peter Oundjian had shushed them.
Source: Metronome |
Source: Shush |
*sigh*
Maybe I just went into this expecting too much. It's one of my favourite violin concerti, and I listen to it every Sunday with my morning coffee (in place of going to church...yes, I know, I'm a bad Catholic). So yes, I did bust out the iPod on the subway and listen to the Joshua Bell version of the Tchaikovsky violin concerto...just to make myself feel better. This night wasn't supposed to go this way. And as much as it pains me to have to say anything bad about the TSO, I have to be objective. I can't say it was good if I didn't like it. I just can't.